Can foil trays go in the oven—specifically in a small countertop toaster oven with exposed elements?

Short answer

Why people ask this

People worry because small toaster ovens have exposed heating elements and very tight clearance. That makes thin aluminum trays behave differently than in a full-size oven. Users also want quick cleanup and portion-sized cooking, which foil trays are great for, but they’re unsure about arcing, scorching, or blocking heat flow. Manuals vary widely: some allow aluminum, others forbid it, especially under broil.

When it might be safe

• Keep at least 1–2 inches of clearance from the top and bottom exposed elements; use the middle rack if available
• Place the foil tray on a solid metal sheet pan to reduce radiant intensity and catch drips
• Use bake (not broil/air broil) and keep temps moderate (generally ≤450°F/230°C unless your manual states lower)
• Avoid overhangs or crumpled foil edges that can drift into elements or the oven walls
• Preheat first, then load quickly to limit the tray sitting near glowing elements with the door open

When it is not safe

• Using broil or any setting that brings food within an inch of glowing exposed elements
• Letting the foil tray or foil lid touch or bow toward the elements or side walls
• Very small ovens where the tray blocks most airflow or covers the crumb tray vents
• Cooking high-fat foods that can splatter onto hot elements from a shallow foil tray

Possible risks

• Element contact causing arcing, scorch marks, or damage to the heating coil
• Radiant heat concentration that warps or scorches thin foil and overheats food surfaces
• Grease flare-ups if drips reach exposed elements or the crumb tray
• Uneven cooking from blocked airflow in the tight cavity
• Manufacturer warranty issues if the manual forbids foil or trays under certain modes

Safer alternatives

• An oven-safe metal or enameled mini sheet pan that fits the rack, with a silicone or wire rack insert
• Shallow ceramic or borosilicate glass dishes rated for your oven’s max temp (avoid broil with glass)
• Reusable small stainless steel trays or loaf pans that keep shape and distance from elements
• Use parchment only on a backing sheet and below its rated temp, keeping it well away from the elements
• Air-fryer–style basket or perforated pan designed for your model to maintain airflow

Bottom line

Check your toaster oven manual first. In a small unit with exposed elements, a foil tray can be fine if it’s on a sheet pan, kept well away from the elements, used on bake at moderate temps, and doesn’t block airflow. Skip broil and anything that brings foil close to glowing coils.

Related questions

Search something else