Can parchment paper go in the oven — tiny toaster oven with a broiler coil inches from your sheet pan

Short answer

Why people ask this

In a compact toaster oven with an exposed top broiler and strong convection fan, running 450°F for 18–22 minutes pushes parchment hard. Renters with ultra‑sensitive smoke detectors and no vent hood worry about smoke or flare‑ups from silicone‑coated parchment rated only to 425°F.

When it might be safe

• Lower the heat to ≤400°F and turn off convection so the 425°F‑rated silicone parchment doesn’t exceed its rating.
• Trim parchment to sit fully flat inside a rimmed pan with no overhang and at least 1–2 inches from side walls so the fan can’t lift it.
• Move the rack lower to increase clearance from the exposed broiler; keep several inches of space above the paper.
• Avoid pooling fat on the paper; drain or blot halfway, or arrange food so drippings land on bare metal, not parchment.
• Watch the first bake closely; if edges darken or curl near the coil, stop and switch to a non‑paper option.

When it is not safe

• Running 450°F convection when your parchment is rated to 425°F—especially with a strong fan that can lift edges toward the broiler.
• Overhanging parchment or sheets placed within about 1 inch of the side walls; a gust can blow it into the exposed top element.
• Top rack only ~3 inches below the broiler coil, shrinking the safety gap around the paper.
• Allowing ~2 tbsp of rendered fat to pool on parchment; if the paper scorches, the grease can flare.
• Swapping in wax paper; it softens, melts, and smokes, tainting food and setting off sensitive alarms.
• If paper ignites or smoking won’t stop: keep the door closed to smother, turn the oven off/unplug; if flames persist or spread, evacuate and call emergency services.

Possible risks

• Paper contacting or getting too close to the broiler coil can ignite.
• Silicone coating charring at high convection heat produces smoke that can easily trip an ultra‑sensitive detector.
• Grease flare‑ups when pooled fat hits scorched paper or a hot element.
• Off‑flavors and residues on the element, causing lingering smoke on future bakes.
• Possible damage to the toaster oven or pan if flames or heavy scorching occur.

Safer alternatives

• Use a bare, rimmed metal sheet (lightly oiled if needed) so drippings hit metal, not paper.
• Line the pan with heavy‑duty foil, crimped tightly with no overhang; keep it clear of the walls and coil.
• Cook on a wire rack set over a rimmed sheet so fat drains to metal; avoid any liners near the broiler.
• Lower temp and/or disable convection to reduce lift and scorching; extend time as needed while monitoring.
• Use a perforated or mesh toaster‑oven tray that promotes airflow without paper.
• If available, cook on the stovetop or in a full‑size oven with better clearance and ventilation.

Bottom line

In this setup—450°F convection, exposed broiler, tight clearances, and pooled fat—skip parchment. If you must use it, reduce heat, disable convection, trim all overhang, increase clearance, and keep fat off the paper; otherwise use metal or foil instead.

Related questions

Search something else